Blog

For people with persistent environmental allergies, immunotherapy offers a long-term solution that can reduce or even eliminate allergy symptoms. Two of the most common forms of immunotherapy are Sublingual Immunotherapy (SLIT) and Subcutaneous Immunotherapy (SCIT). Both approaches aim to desensitize the immune system to specific allergens, but they differ in how they are administered and the experiences they provide.

In this blog post, we'll break down the similarities and differences between SLIT and SCIT, helping you make an informed choice if you’re considering allergy immunotherapy.

‍

What Is Allergy Immunotherapy?

Allergy immunotherapy works by exposing your immune system to gradually increasing doses of an allergen, helping your body build up tolerance over time. This approach addresses the root cause of allergies, offering lasting relief, unlike symptom management treatments like antihistamines.

Immunotherapy is most commonly used for allergies to:

• Pollen (grass, tree, or weed pollen)
• Dust mites
• Animal dander (e.g., cats or dogs)
• Mold
• Stinging insects (in some cases)

Both SLIT and SCIT are forms of immunotherapy, but their delivery methods and processes differ.

‍

What Is Subcutaneous Immunotherapy (SCIT)?

Subcutaneous Immunotherapy, commonly known as allergy shots, has been used for over a century to treat allergies. In SCIT, allergens are injected directly into the skin, typically in the upper arm. The injections are administered at a healthcare provider’s office.

• Initial Phase: During the build-up phase, patients receive injections one to two times a week for 3-6 months. The allergen dose gradually increases over time.
• Maintenance Phase: Once the optimal dose is reached, patients typically receive maintenance shots every 3-4 weeks for 3-5 years.

‍

What Is Sublingual Immunotherapy (SLIT)?

Sublingual Immunotherapy, on the other hand, involves placing drops or tablets containing the allergen under the tongue. SLIT is self-administered at home after the first dose is given in a doctor’s office to monitor for any adverse reactions.

• Initial Phase: Similar to SCIT, SLIT starts with a build-up phase, but it is administered daily. The allergen dose is gradually increased.
• Maintenance Phase: After the build-up period, patients continue taking daily doses for 3-5 years, just like SCIT.

‍

Comparing SLIT and SCIT: Key Similarities

Before diving into the differences, let's look at how SLIT and SCIT are alike:

1. Long-Term Allergy Relief

Both SLIT and SCIT aim to desensitize the immune system to allergens, providing long-term relief from allergy symptoms. Studies show that after completing the full course of treatment, patients may experience lasting benefits for years.

2. Safety and Efficacy

Both forms of immunotherapy are generally considered safe and effective. Numerous studies have shown that both SLIT and SCIT significantly reduce allergy symptoms and the need for medication over time.

3. Tailored to Specific Allergens

Whether you choose SLIT or SCIT, the treatment is personalized based on your specific allergy profile. Your allergist will develop a treatment plan that targets the allergens most responsible for your symptoms.

How SLIT and SCIT Differ: A Closer Look

Now that we’ve covered the similarities, let’s explore the major differences between SLIT and SCIT, from convenience and cost to side effects and effectiveness.

1. Administration Method

• SCIT (Allergy Shots): Requires regular injections administered by a healthcare professional in a clinic setting.
• SLIT (Allergy Drops/Tablets): Taken orally at home, which offers more flexibility and convenience for those with busy schedules or difficulty making frequent visits to a doctor’s office.

2. Frequency and Convenience

• SCIT: Patients typically need to visit their allergist 1-2 times per week during the initial phase, which can be time-consuming. The maintenance phase reduces the frequency to monthly visits.
• SLIT: Can be self-administered at home daily, eliminating the need for frequent clinic visits. This can be more convenient for those with busy lives or limited access to an allergist’s office.

3. Side Effects

• SCIT: The most common side effects of SCIT are localized to the injection site, such as redness, swelling, or itching. Rarely, more severe systemic reactions, such as anaphylaxis, can occur, which is why SCIT must be administered in a doctor’s office where immediate medical attention is available.
• SLIT: SLIT generally has fewer systemic side effects compared to SCIT. Common side effects include mild oral itching or tingling. Severe allergic reactions are rare, but patients are usually monitored after the first dose.

4. Effectiveness

• SCIT: Has been around longer and is considered the gold standard for allergy immunotherapy. It is effective for a broader range of allergens, including pollen, dust mites, animal dander, mold, and stinging insect allergies.
• SLIT: Is similarly effective for treating pollen and dust mite allergies but is not widely used for stinging insect allergies. Some studies suggest SLIT may not be quite as effective as SCIT for certain allergens, but it is still a highly effective treatment option for most environmental allergies.

5. Duration of Treatment

• SCIT: Typically takes 3-6 months to complete the build-up phase and requires maintenance shots for 3-5 years.
• SLIT: The build-up phase is shorter, but the treatment still takes 3-5 years. Daily administration is required, which can be a downside for people who struggle with consistency.

6. Cost

• SCIT: Allergy shots tend to be covered by insurance, but costs may accumulate due to frequent visits to the allergist. Out-of-pocket costs can vary depending on the number of allergens in the treatment and insurance coverage.
• SLIT: SLIT may be more expensive than SCIT because it is not as widely covered by insurance in some countries, including the U.S. However, SLIT saves on travel and time costs associated with frequent doctor visits.

7. Allergen Range

• SCIT: Covers a wide range of allergens, including pollen, dust mites, mold, animal dander, and stinging insects.
• SLIT: Is most commonly used for pollen,mold and dust mite allergies and is not typically used for stinging insects allergies.

‍

Which Treatment Is Right for You?

Choosing between SLIT and SCIT depends on various factors, including your lifestyle, allergy severity, and personal preferences. Here’s a quick summary to help you decide:

• Choose SCIT (Allergy Shots) if:some text
  • You’re comfortable with regular injections.
  • You can commit to frequent visits to your allergist’s office.
  • You need treatment for a wide range of allergens, including insect stings.
• Choose SLIT (Allergy Drops/Tablets) if:some text
  • You prefer the convenience of home administration.
  • You have a busy schedule or live far from an allergist.
  • You’re primarily allergic to pollen or dust mites and want to avoid injections.

‍

Conclusion

Both SLIT and SCIT offer effective, long-term relief for allergy sufferers by targeting the root cause of allergic reactions. While SCIT is more established and treats a broader range of allergens, SLIT provides a convenient, at-home alternative for those seeking flexibility. Discussing your specific allergies and treatment goals with our clinic is the best way to determine which immunotherapy is right for you.